Stories & Thyme

making space for creativity

Menu
  • About
    • Amy’s Favorite Things
  • Connect
  • Eat
  • Motherhood
  • Move
  • Pray
  • Read
    • Amy’s Favorite Books
    • Children’s Picture Book Lists
    • Favorite Children’s Christmas Books
    • Favorite Christian Children’s Bibles & Books
    • Favorite Early Readers & First Chapter Books
    • Favorite Resources for the 3Rs – Reading, Writing, and Arithmetic
    • Newbery Award Book Reviews
Menu

Newbery Review # 32 (Secret of the Andes, Clark, 1953)

Posted on February 18, 2016 by Amy Rogers Hays

Secret of the Andes       

 

The 1953 Newbery Award winning book, Secret of the Andes by Ann Nolan Clark, follows a young indigenous Peruvian llama shepherd, Cusi, as he seeks to discover why he has been raised by a mysterious old wise man, Chuto, in an isolated Andean valley. Cusi and his companion, Misti the llama, travel first to the sea and then alone to the ancient city, Cuzco, to find the answers at which Chuto has only hinted.

 

 

Secret of the Andes Cush and Llamas

 

What I liked. The whole book is written in a very poetic voice with beautiful lines and descriptions popping up amid the very mature sounding musings of little Cusi. For example, when Cusi and Chuto come to stay the night with some of Chuto’s friends, the women “laughed behind their hands, but Cusi knew that was their way. No one had told him, but he understood that a welcome does not need to be expressed by words or gestures. If the heart speaks to the stranger, the stranger feels at home.” (p. 38)

 

Secret of the Andes poem 

 

What was interesting. I thought that the actual “secret” and reason that Cusi was raised by Chuto was a compelling one that was consistent with the tone of the book. I was a little surprised because as the book was drawing to a close I couldn’t really guess what exactly could wrap up the story in only a few pages, but it did. (No, I’m not going to tell you what it is! You have to read it for yourself!!)

 

 Secret of the Andes the secret

 

What were some limitations. I’m not entirely sure this is a limitation, but Secret of the Andes won the Newbery the year that EB White’s Charlotte’s Web only won a Newbery Honor. Children’s literary critic Anita Silvery in her 2008 School Library Journal article  wrote about the 1953 Newbery year: “A member of the 1953 Newbery committee, which chose The Secret of the Andes (Viking, 1952) over E. B. White’s masterpiece, Charlotte’s Web (Harper, 1952), confessed that she preferred the former because she hadn’t seen any good books about South America…[and Silvery concludes] But I know that the good is often the enemy of the best. The Secret of the Andes is a good book; Charlotte’s Web, the best. Recent Newbery committees seem to be hunting for the former—when they should be desperately searching for the latter.” The insinuation is that the books in the early 2000s that won the Newbery did so because they were a bit more about filling a multicultural curriculum requirement for elementary school reading than because they were the very best books that children would love. And I think that to some extent the challenge of any book award is that you can’t really compare and rank books very objectively. I think that I too would prefer to read and recommend Charlotte’s Web over Secret of the Andes, but after reading the first 32 Newberies, I agree with the unnamed committee member that (at least among Newbery winners) South American set children’s books were thin on the ground. And the first decade of Newbery winners had some distinctly racist sentiments, which I think could be balanced out with some books that have protagonists that are from different cultures and backgrounds. Although of course at the same time, a lot of the early Newberies were multicultural; it’s just that they were also exoticized. I’m not an expert on Peruvian indigenous culture to speak with any authority about whether Secrets of the Andes is a particularly faithful rendering of Incan llama herding descendants, but to me it seemed that Ann Nolan Clark did a fair bit of research in creating Cusi and his world.

 

 Secret of the Andes inca

 

Similarity to other Newbery winners. Tales from the Silverlands is a (uneven) collection of South American Folktales, while Call it Courage and Waterless Mountain are two coming of age stories of indigenous boys (one in Polynesia and one in Arizona) — so there were other Newberies that touched on some of the themes and settings of Secret of the Andes.

 

 Secret of the Andes the steep trail

 

What it teaches me as a writer. I suppose the real lesson of thinking about Charlotte’s Web and Secret of the Andes together is that awards, like the Newbery, are helpful, but ultimately incredibly limited. Just like one star reviews of Harry Potter remind me, not everyone loves the books I love. And not everyone is going to love my book—even if it’s quite good (and I hope it will be!). Literary taste is subjective; sometimes we read books at the wrong time, or we read books that normally wouldn’t speak to us at the exact time they unexpectedly do. Really, I think that a good book recommendation is probably more valuable than a book award, although I am sure that the award givers hope that they can at times be one and the same.

 

Secret of the Andes sandles

 

 

Have you read Secrets of the Andes? What are your favorite award winning or NOT award winning books? And do you think that subject matter should influence literary awards?

 

*Note* This post contains Amazon affiliate links, which means if you were to buy a book, I’d get a tiny commission at no cost to you. Thanks for supporting Stories & Thyme!*

 

 

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Welcome!

PageLines- amyrogershays.JPG
I'm so glad you're here! I'm Amy - Anglican, mother of two, lover of trees, coffee, & fairy tales. Here's where I write about making space for creativity and filling our days with long walks, good food, morning prayers, and the reading and writing of good books. Drop me a line at AmyRogersHays (at) gmail.com.

follow us in feedly

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Instagram

instagram walk in snow

Follow Me on Instagram!

Recent Posts

  • Maundy Thursday: A Liturgy for Children and Families
  • Family Easter Basket Ideas: Books, Games, and Really Good Chocolate
  • Newbery Review #104 (The First State of Being, Kelly, 2025)
  • 40 Books for My 40th Birthday: A 2024 Reading List
  • Family Christmas Letter 2024

Twitter

spring robin outline on budding branches Follow me on Twitter!

Categories

  • Anxiety
  • baby
  • Board Games
  • Book Lists
  • Children's Spiritual Formation
  • Connect
  • Creativity
  • Eat
  • Family Stories
  • Fun with Kids
  • Liturgical year
  • Love & Marriage
  • Make
  • Motherhood
  • Move
  • Newbery Book Reviews
  • Order
  • paleo
  • Pray
  • pregnancy
  • Read
  • Reflections
  • Rest
  • Self-Care
  • simplify
  • Toddler
  • Travel
  • Uncategorized
  • walks in the woods
  • Wisconsin Beauty
  • Write

Favorite Posts

natural haircare

Make Natural Hair Care: Baking Soda, Apple Cider Vinegar & Vodka-Gelatin Hair Gel

  homemade deodorant

Make Homemade Deodorant For Sensitive Skin: Bentonite Clay and Baking Soda

  college advice

Advice to Future College Students: 10 Things I Wish I Had Done More

  belonging to a church

Belonging to A Church

  dyslexia

Reflections on Dyslexia: May B. A Novel by Caroline Starr Rose

  leaving grad school

A Defining Retreat: Deciding to Leave Grad School

  love story

The Beginning of a Love Story In Honor of Anniversary Weekend

  breakfast

Scramble Up A Simple Paleo Breakfast

  cake

Bake Up A Flourless Chocolate Cake

  comfortable and presentable

Organize Bookshelves by Color

  trees

My Life In Trees

  elimination diet

An Elimination Diet Figure Out What Foods Are Making You Sick

  goodbye letter

A Goodbye Letter to Our Church: Leaving Those You Love

  paleo blended chai recipe

Paleo Chai: A Blended Coconut Oil & Butter Recipe

  Prayer book

16 Online Resources: Liturgical Prayer Apps & Websites

 

Archives

Welcome!


I’m so glad you’re here! I’m Amy – Anglican, mother of two, lover of trees, coffee, & fairy tales. Here’s where I write about making space for creativity and filling our days with long walks, good food, morning prayers, and the reading and writing of good books. Drop me a line at AmyRogersHays (at) gmail.com.

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 744 other subscribers

Instagram

instagram walk in snow

Follow Me on Instagram!

Search

Recent Posts

Maundy Thursday: A Liturgy for Children and Families

Maundy Thursday: A Liturgy for Children and Families

Family Easter Basket Ideas: Books, Games, and Really Good Chocolate

Family Easter Basket Ideas: Books, Games, and Really Good Chocolate

Newbery Review #104 (The First State of Being, Kelly, 2025)

Newbery Review #104 (The First State of Being, Kelly, 2025)

40 Books for My 40th Birthday: A 2024 Reading List

40 Books for My 40th Birthday: A 2024 Reading List

Family Christmas Letter 2024

Family Christmas Letter 2024

Recipe for a Birthday Hike

Recipe for a Birthday Hike

An Invitation to October Rest: A Devotional

An Invitation to October Rest: A Devotional

Fun for Two: 5 Date Night Board & Card Games

Fun for Two: 5 Date Night Board & Card Games

Our Board-Game Loving, Third Grade Son’s Top 5 List of Favorite Board Games

Our Board-Game Loving, Third Grade Son’s Top 5 List of Favorite Board Games

Our First Grader’s Top Board Games: 5 No-Reading-Required, Travel Friendly, Family Card Games

Our First Grader’s Top Board Games: 5 No-Reading-Required, Travel Friendly, Family Card Games

5 Games to Start a Board Game Collection

5 Games to Start a Board Game Collection

5 Tips for Family Board Gaming

5 Tips for Family Board Gaming

40 of the Best Picture Books for 5 Year Olds

40 of the Best Picture Books for 5 Year Olds

Newbery Review #103 (The Eyes and the Impossible, Egger, 2024)

Newbery Review #103 (The Eyes and the Impossible, Egger, 2024)

Ash Wednesday: A Liturgy for Children and Families

Ash Wednesday: A Liturgy for Children and Families

Ways to Feel a Little Better or a Little More Peaceful

Ways to Feel a Little Better or a Little More Peaceful

How to Find Great Children’s Books: 20 Guide Books, Books Lists, and Web Resources

How to Find Great Children’s Books: 20 Guide Books, Books Lists, and Web Resources

39 Books for my 39th Birthday: A 2023 Reading List

39 Books for my 39th Birthday: A 2023 Reading List

Family Christmas Letter 2023

Family Christmas Letter 2023

A Simple Home Christmas Pageant Script

A Simple Home Christmas Pageant Script

Books & Boots for Saint Nicholas Day: A List of our Family’s Favorite Christmas Picture and Read Aloud Books

Books & Boots for Saint Nicholas Day: A List of our Family’s Favorite Christmas Picture and Read Aloud Books

40 Great Picture Books for 4 Year Olds

40 Great Picture Books for 4 Year Olds

Newbery Review #102 (Freewater, Luqman-Dawson, 2023)

Newbery Review #102 (Freewater, Luqman-Dawson, 2023)

The Best Children’s Bibles: 30+ suggestions from Board Book Bibles to Illustrated Study Bibles

The Best Children’s Bibles: 30+ suggestions from Board Book Bibles to Illustrated Study Bibles

An Epiphany Liturgy for Children and Families

An Epiphany Liturgy for Children and Families

Categories

  • Anxiety
  • baby
  • Board Games
  • Book Lists
  • Children's Spiritual Formation
  • Connect
  • Creativity
  • Eat
  • Family Stories
  • Fun with Kids
  • Liturgical year
  • Love & Marriage
  • Make
  • Motherhood
  • Move
  • Newbery Book Reviews
  • Order
  • paleo
  • Pray
  • pregnancy
  • Read
  • Reflections
  • Rest
  • Self-Care
  • simplify
  • Toddler
  • Travel
  • Uncategorized
  • walks in the woods
  • Wisconsin Beauty
  • Write

Favorite Posts

natural haircare

Make
Natural Hair Care: Baking Soda, Apple Cider Vinegar & Vodka-Gelatin Hair Gel

 

homemade deodorant

Make
Homemade Deodorant For Sensitive Skin: Bentonite Clay and Baking Soda

 

college advice

Advice to Future College Students: 10 Things I Wish I Had Done More

 

belonging to a church

Belonging to A Church

 

dyslexia

Reflections on Dyslexia:
May B. A Novel by Caroline Starr Rose

 

leaving grad school

A Defining Retreat: Deciding to Leave Grad School

 

love story

The Beginning of a Love Story In Honor of Anniversary Weekend

 

breakfast

Scramble Up A Simple Paleo Breakfast

 

cake

Bake Up A Flourless Chocolate Cake

 

comfortable and presentable

Organize Bookshelves by Color

 

trees

My Life In Trees

 

elimination diet

An Elimination Diet Figure Out What Foods Are Making You Sick

 

goodbye letter

A Goodbye Letter to Our Church: Leaving Those You Love

 

paleo blended chai recipe

Paleo Chai: A Blended Coconut Oil & Butter Recipe

 

Prayer book

16 Online Resources: Liturgical Prayer Apps & Websites

 

© 2025 Stories & Thyme | Powered by Minimalist Blog WordPress Theme