After the marathon 500 page history book, The Voyages of Dr. Dolittle was a quick and fun read. It was about a fifth as long, and perhaps a fifth as difficult as the first Newbery Winner The Story of Mankind.  Dr. Doolittle is by far the most popular of the 1920s Newbery Winners. It is part of a long series of books (and later movies) by Hugh Lofting about a doctor who can communicate with animals.


page 5 feet in water


I didn’t grow up watching the movies, but Evan did, and loved the 1967 musical version with Rex Harrison. I liked the book enough that I am curious now to see the movie adaptations. The Newbery winning Dr. Dolittle book is the second book in the series which has a 10 year old boy, Tommy Stubbins, as narrator recalling his sea voyage from England with the great naturalist Dr. John Dolittle in search of the lost native naturalist Long Arrow on Spider Island.


page 133


What I liked. The concept of talking with animals is really whimsical, and the best parts of the books are the animals themselves. I loved the duck house keeper DabDab and the wise fluent-English parrot Polynesia. Lofting creates some fun situations for animals to help, such as a dog as a witness in court, bulls who help put on a show during a bull fight, parrots winning a war by nipping the enemies’ ear lobes, whales pushing an island, and a snail acting as a submarine.


page 189 bull fight


What was interesting. I was fascinated by the depiction of the turn-of-the-century naturalist and animal rights. Although it has a very different feel from Black Beauty or The Evolution of Calpurnia Tate, it does seem to capture the late 19th century fascination with the animals and plants that Charles Darwin was cataloging and theorizing about in his own writings. John Dolittle’s secret discovery of the north pole or the concept of how various animal languages were connected echoes a wider shift in scientific thinking and practice during that period.


page 175 in spain


What were some limitationsSimilar to The Story of Mankind, there is definitely some orientalism and racism in this book. The depiction (and names!) of the African prince Bumpo and the South American Popsipetels natives leaves a lot to be desired. They are clownish and naive, dependent on the benevolent wisdom and power of Dr. Dolittle. Also, there are remarkably few female human characters (although a lot of great female animals).


page 293 whales pushing the island


Why I think it’s a Newbery:  There is so much packed into this book: a sea adventure, stow-aways, a murder case, talking animals, a bull fight, a rescue attempt, a war, a snail submarine. It just is a really fun book!


page 115 dog gives evidence


Similarity to other Newbery winners. Like Story of Mankind, there is definitely a very international and broad scope to this book, but from within the worldview of Europe at the center.


page 53 kitchen


What it teaches me as a writer: I think that Dolittle really encouraged me to remember that well-thought out whimsical and fun situations really can carry a book. Especially where I am in the drafting process, having a lot of fun and whimsy is important. (Tree houses! Doors behind waterfalls! Underground castles!)


page 226 shipwreacked


Have you read (or watched) Dr. Dolittle? Or what are the whimsical books you loved as a child?


6 Responses to Newbery Review #2 (Dr. Dolittle, Lofting, 1923)

  1. I read every Dr. Dolittle book I could get my hands on when I was in fifth grade.

    • Amy Rogers Hays says:

      I can imagine! I had no idea that it was a series! I sort of wish I could just read 12 other Dr. Dolittle books instead of so many folk tale collections that are in front of me on the Newbery list 🙂

  2. Thanks for these! I’m taking notes for when I can go through these books with my daughter. 🙂

  3. Amy Rogers Hays says:

    Yeah, Dr. Dolittle is pretty fun. Some of the newer editions of have taken out some of the really offensive racial terms. Which I think that Lofting would have approved of, I don’t think he would have used those words if he were writing today. So it’s worth reading a newer edition with Miss L.

  4. Anne Hays says:

    I loved the Dr. Doolittle books and I am sure I have read them all. You mentioned the 1967 movie and that brings back memories of the time I took Doug and Peter to England and Scotland when we lived in Germany. Peter must have been 9 and a bit bored with the sights of London when he spotted the then-new Dr. Doolittle movie showing. He begged to go, so we stopped seeing London and saw Dr. Doolittle! I would enjoy seeing the movie again. More recently but still long time ago, Jim and I anchored in Marigot Bay, where a lot of the movie was filmed.
    Again, a good review. You do a good job of backing up your comments with specifics from the book.
    Keep reading and writing.

    • Amy Rogers Hays says:

      I love that story about going and seeing Dr. Dolittle. Well Doug must have loved it, because Evan and Colleen saw it a lot growing up! The only thing I remember about that movie is seeing the end with the giant snail and that beautiful island, which must have been Marigot Bay. Wow that would be very cool to anchor there. We miss you guys and sailing with you!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *